Raymand Vannieuwenhoven Wiki
Biography of Lehmand van Nieuwwenhofen
Who is Lehmann van Nieuwwenhofen?
Relatives of a Green Bay couple killed 45 years ago said they were delighted with the conviction of the couple’s killer, an elderly Lakewood man, on Tuesday.
“He gave up on me years ago,” says De Pere’s Jo-Anne Mikulsky. “I’ve always hoped, but…”
After about two hours of deliberation, a Marinette County jury found Raymand Vannieuwenhoven guilty of two counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of David Schuldes, 25, and Ellen Matheys, 24.
The couple were shot dead at McClintock Park camp on July 9, 1976.
Vannieuwenhoven, 84, was charged in March 2019 in connection with a crime using “genetic genealogy,” which has been used over the past three years to identify suspects in dozens of cases around the world a decade ago people. nation.
Schuldes’ sister Mikulsky said Vannieuwenhoven’s conviction left her and her mother in limbo.
“Justice is another matter,” Mikulski said. “He left them for 45 years when they were just starting their lives and 43 of those 45 years were spent in business and they were free to live their lives. So is there any fairness and justice there? ? No, but we’re happy. It’s what they left and we’re happy to receive it.”
Matheys’ niece, Lori Smith, from Green Bay, said the families had been “fighting, grieving, waiting” since his death.
“This man went on to live his life, and we all suffered for . . . (for) 45 years,” Smith said. “He doesn’t seem remorseful at all, but justice will be served eventually.”
In closing arguments Tuesday morning, Marinette County District Attorney DeShea Morrow highlighted the presence of Vannieuwenhoven’s DNA at the crime scene.
“Raymand Vannieuwenhoven is the only person on earth who could be the source of the semen on Ellen Matheys shorts,” Morrow told the jury. “You can trust this because it’s been scientifically proven.”
Morrow said Schulders was shot outside the women’s bathroom, where she was waiting for Mathis to go out for a walk. When she came out, she was probably led into the woods at gunpoint.
Although Schulders died almost immediately from a shot in the neck, Morrow said the final minutes of Massey’s life were “absolutely horrific”.
Morrow noted jury testimony from pathologist Dr. Robert Collis, who said she was shot once while standing and once on the ground. When she was found on the ground, she showed a photo of Matheys partially dressed, with his shirt over her head and her underwear in the background, telling the jury it was not a consensual act.
“Raymand Vannieuwenhoven just saw an opportunity,” Morrow said. “He killed David Schulders to let him go, then he raped Ellen Mathis, then he killed her.”
Defense attorney Lee Schuchart reminded the jury that they were not arguing that the state could prove that Vannieuwenhoven’s DNA was on Matheys’ shorts, and that crime lab analysts couldn’t prove who, when or why it was deposited.
“DNA is just one piece of the puzzle…” Schuchat said. “That’s the physical evidence they have that links Ray to this crime. They don’t prove beyond a shadow of a doubt that Ray shot David and shot Allen.”
Much of Schuchat’s epilogue focused on the testimony of two friends who passed by McClintock Park that day, suggesting that others were the killers.
“Two witnesses saw the gunman with the murder weapon and walking towards the fleeing vehicle,” Schuchat said.
He was referring to Plymouth, which the couple and another witness saw on their way to the camp. This car has Michigan license plates.
The couple described the man, armed with a 30-30 rifle, of slim build, about 6ft tall, with medium length brown hair and a mustache. One of the two witnesses, Schuchat, said he had a “good look” at the man with the rifle, who he said was no older than 28.
Schuchat said it didn’t match Van Nieuwvenhoven, who was shorter, had short, clean shaven hair and looked older than he was at 39 at the time.
Despite a thorough investigation by the Marinette County Sheriff’s Office after identifying Vannieuwenhoven, they were unable to link him to the weapon (the murder weapon was never found), Plymouth with Michigan license plates, the victim, or even McLean Get in touch with Tok Park.
He said the situation “looked like someone who knew (the victim) would be there” and he attacked them.
Schuchat also questioned the destruction of some evidence, but Morrow tentatively called the practice customary, explaining that today’s retention policy is much stricter than it was decades ago.
However, he said, “the most important piece of evidence in this case, the shorts, has been preserved.”
Mark Williams and Don Garn
“He left his mark, and 42 years later, he was recognized,” Morrow said.
As for the lack of other evidence, he said it took Vannieuwenhoven more than 40 years to dispose of the rifle after collecting the casings.
Morrow also suggested that the descriptions of the man with the gun by the two witnesses were not necessarily very different from those of Van Nieuwwenhoven at the time. She showed a photo of him circa 1976, in which he appeared to be shaded by a bushy beard, and said the man could only be seen from the side “with a glance” and then in the rearview mirror.
As for Schuchat’s belief that the “getaway car” was just another car parked on the side of the road, Morrow said.
“Look at the whole situation,” she urged the jury.
Mikulsky and Smith thank the Sheriff’s Office, state crime lab staff and investigators who have been working on the case since the murders, as well as Morrow and Special Counsels Mark Williams and Don Gahn for their efforts.
Smith noted that the couple was murdered two months before their wedding.
“The lives and futures of Ellie and Dave have been stolen from them, as has everyone who knew and loved them,” she said.
“I wonder every day what their future holds,” Smith added. “The world also loses because I’m going to have kids, and those kids are going to be blessed and who knows what impact they’ll have.”