‘Colonial India’s Dissenting Judge’ review: A biography of Syed Mahmood

‘Dissenting Judges in Colonial India’ Review: Biography of Syed Mahmood, #Colonial #Indias #Dissenting #Judge #reviewA #biography #ofSyed #Mahmood Welcome to 50 Mind BlogHere is our latest breaking news and trending broadcast for you today: :

Express Online News Service

This 200-page account of India’s first Muslim judge of the High Court of Allahabad who dared to dissent and chose to resign as senior chairman of the judiciary rather than kowtow before a British ruler is a thorough take on the legend and system builder Research description.

Dissent Judges in Syed Mahmood Colonial India by Mohammad Nasir and Samreen Ahmed shares the positives and negatives of Mahmood’s life and work details, while attempting to gain popular acceptance and build trust for British colonial rule after the upheaval of 1857.

In his short 53 years, Mahmoud, son of Sir Syed Ahmed, not only acquired skills in Arabic, Persian, Sanskrit, English, Latin, but also went on to complete his legal education, gaining the Barrister’s qualifications. Degree from Christ’s College, Cambridge University. By the time he joined the Indian civil service as a district judge in 1879, he had written a review of the Indian Act of Evidence and laid the foundations of the Muhammad Anglo-Oriental (MAO) Academy, which led to the establishment of the Aligarh Muslim University .

Dissent judge in colonial India examines Syed Mahmood's biographyHis achievements in law, jurisprudence and education, especially with regard to Muslims, must be read to be believed. An intellectual and a genius, he became the first Muslim and the youngest High Court judge under the British Empire in India. In fact, at the time, it was the highest rung of the judicial ladder in British India.

Mahmoud, through his “dissent, became a shredder in line with the colonial judicial conventions of British judges”, and when forced to submit, he also had the courage and conviction to resign as coveted chairman, insisting on his independence and equality as between equals judge.

He refused to be abused by Chief Justice Sir John Edge, who was bent on bureaucratically punishing a principled dissident colleague. During his brief six-year tenure as a High Court judge and 14 years as a judicial career, Mahmoud successfully pioneered “the synthesis between ancient Hindu and Islamic law and the common law instilled directly or through English statutes” and went on to become a text, and many of his judgments go on to be landmarks in the history and practice of Indian justice. Even his dissent is seen as the basis of conduct and laws around the world today.

“When a mode of interpretation endorsed by the highest authority Hindu logicians is on the horizon, it is a clear mistake to bring in foreign ideas and use them to interpret Sanskrit texts,” observes Mahmood, reflecting his integrity and comprehensiveness command.

In addition to his professional achievements, his versatile and down-to-earth personality worked hard to build the pillars of judicial freedom, educational empowerment and tolerance, the “Indian idea” that evolved and was enshrined in the Constitution in the struggle for freedom.

In today’s climate of growing intolerance and religious prejudice, Mahmoud stands out as a man of faith and interfaith, and his wisdom is reflected in his assessment of the Mughal Empire. “What made Akbar’s rule so prominent and prosperous…His army was far smaller than what he (Aurangzeb) had assembled…” He asked a question and went on to answer it himself – “The strength of the moral cause he Completely ignored, he did not consult the feelings of his subjects”.

In Mahmoud’s view, “Aurangzeb was a poor statesman – his statesmanship depended on marital discipline and physical strength; he did not realize the potential of the ‘friendly model’ on which his ancestors depended, Especially Akbar’s reliance on administration.”

The author of “Syed Mahmood: A Dissent Judge in Colonial India” has done a commendable job of presenting his life and achievements to a generation ignorant of ancestral contributions. But the pair also realized not to turn the book into a eulogy. They did not overlook or ignore Mahmood’s weaknesses, such as his addiction to alcohol, which may have prematurely ended his glorious life.

A biography either becomes a biography, or sometimes an indispensable source of history. This is definitely the latter.

Syed Mahmoud: Dissent Judges Mohammad Nasir, Samrin Ahmed in Colonial India
Publisher: Bloomsbury
Pages: 274
Price: Rs 699

Leave a Comment